I just listened to the most recent episode of the Eleanor & Alisdair Read That podcast, where they talked about the book Heidi. And it occurred to me that someone should break down just what the difference is between Heidi and Pollyanna. I’m throwing in another couple of comparable characters too. You’ll never confuse them again!
| Heidi | Pollyanna | Pippi Longstocking | Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Name: | Adelheid Hessen | Pollyanna Whittier | Pippilotta Delicatessa Windowshade Mackrelmint Efraimsdotter Longstocking | Rebecca Rowena Randall |
| Author: | Johanna Spyri | Eleanor H. Porter | Astrid Lindgren | Kate Douglas Wiggin |
| First Published: | 1880 | 1913 | 1945 | 1903 |
| Setting: | Switzerland | Vermont | Sweden | Maine |
| Age at Start: | 5 yrs old | 11 yrs old | 9 yrs old | 10 yrs old |
| Family Sitch: | Orphaned, lives with her crusty old grandfather | Orphaned, lives with a stern aunt | Lives on her own; father is a pirate | Family is poor; lives with two aunts |
| Personality: | Very cheerful and everyone likes her, eventually | Very cheerful and everyone likes her, eventually | Very cheerful and everyone likes her, eventually | Very cheerful and everyone likes her, eventually |
| What’s It About? | Aw, poor little Heidi | Pollyanna will find the silver lining in any cloud | Pippi is the strongest girl in the world and will save the day | Rebecca will find the silver lining in any cloud, but with capitalism |
| Does a girl in a wheelchair walk again? | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Verdict: | Probably readable | Probably intolerable | Fun, but too wacky for grownups | I don’t want to hear it |
| Sequels? | Lots | Lots | Lots | Some |
I suppose I could have included, like, Laura Ingalls, and Anne of Green Gables, and Sara Crewe, but there’s no confusion about them, right? We’ve got them pretty well pinned down?
I haven’t read these books; I’m just curating the information for your benefit. You’re welcome. I did read the Pippi books when I was a kid, and enjoyed them, but I bounced hard off them when I tried revisiting them as a grownup.
One other thing to mention: in 1968, there was an exciting NFL game whose TV broadcast got cut off at the end because the network wanted to show a kids’ movie. That was Heidi. Football fans blew their stacks. As a result of which, I missed lots of episodes of The Wonderful World of Disney in the ’70s because football ran overtime and we just had to wait it out. The games are supposed to be one hour plus breaks! Schedule for it!